The Yankees superstar claimed his second straight MVP honor after a historic 2025 season, leading MLB in nearly every offensive metric while sparking debate about one of the closest races in recent memory.
Aaron Judge has done it again. The New York Yankees slugger was named the 2025 American League MVP for the second consecutive year on November 13, 2025, capping off what can only be described as a dominant regular season that has solidified his place among baseball's all-time greats.
Judge's 2025 campaign was nothing short of historic. He led Major League Baseball in nearly every offensive metric that matters, including 137 runs scored (1st in AL), a .457 on-base percentage (1st in AL), and a 1.145 OPS (1st in AL). The Yankees captain also secured his first batting title while launching 53 home runs, adding another chapter to what has become an extraordinary career trajectory.
A Season of Superlatives
What makes Judge's achievement even more remarkable is the consistency he's maintained at the highest level. This marks his
fourth consecutive season with an OPS over 1.000 and his
fourth season with at least 40 home runs, a testament to his ability to perform under pressure year after year.
The numbers tell a compelling story. Judge accumulated
372 total bases (1st in AL) and led the majors in
Wins Above Replacement calculations from both Baseball-Reference (9.3) and FanGraphs (9.6). These aren't just impressive statistics—they represent the kind of all-around excellence that separates generational talents from merely great players.
Despite a midseason right elbow injury that slowed his pace, Judge still managed to put together what could have been his best season yet. The fact that he overcame this setback and still dominated the competition speaks volumes about his resilience and commitment to excellence.
The MVP Debate: Judge vs. Raleigh
This year's MVP race wasn't without controversy. Seattle Mariners catcher
Cal Raleigh mounted a compelling challenge, hitting an impressive
60 home runs for a franchise that hadn't won its division in a generation. The debate highlighted an ongoing tension in baseball analytics—how do you measure the intangible value of a catcher's contributions, including framing and game management?
However, Judge's statistical superiority proved decisive. The
177-point OPS difference between Judge and Raleigh was roughly as large as the gap between Raleigh and Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Andy Pages, illustrating just how dominant Judge's offensive performance truly was.
Building a Hall of Fame Resume
Judge's second MVP award adds another prestigious credential to what is shaping up to be a Hall of Fame career. He's now won the award twice in four years, and if he continues on this trajectory, his eventual Hall of Fame plaque will feature an impressive collection of accolades and records.
Beyond the MVP hardware, Judge also claimed the
2025 Hank Aaron Award, further cementing his status as one of baseball's most complete and feared hitters.
What's Next?
As the Yankees head into the postseason, all eyes will be on whether Judge can translate his regular season dominance into October success. The team will be counting on their captain to deliver when it matters most, and based on his 2025 performance, there's every reason to believe he's ready for the challenge.
Judge's second consecutive MVP award isn't just a personal achievement—it's a statement about excellence, consistency, and the kind of transcendent talent that defines an era of baseball.
1.
2025 AL MVP Aaron Judge Secured First Batting Title2.
Cal Raleigh, Aaron Judge Battling for 2025 AL MVP - MLB.com3.
Facing Aaron Judge: Best Stories of Pitching to Yankees Star - ESPN4.
Aaron Judge Stats, Age, Position - MLB.com5.
Aaron Judge Wins 2025 AL Hank Aaron Award - MLB.com**
Sources
1. 2025 AL MVP Aaron Judge secured his first batting title and hit 53 ...
2. Cal Raleigh, Aaron Judge battling for 2025 AL MVP - MLB.com
3. Facing Aaron Judge: Best stories of pitching to Yankees star - ESPN
4. Aaron Judge Stats, Age, Position, Height, Weight, Fantasy & News
5. Aaron Judge reacts to winning 2025 MVP - MLB.com
6. Yankees news: Aaron Judge finishes historic regular season
7. Latest Yankees News | New York Yankees - MLB.com
8. Yanks Go Yard: NY Yankees News, Rumors & Fan Community
9. Yankees news: Bullpen redesign incoming - Pinstripe Alley
