New York Giants kicker Jude McAtamney is facing harsh scrutiny after missing two extra points in a crucial game, but the Irish rookie isn't making excuses. In a candid post-game interview, McAtamney delivered a powerful message that resonated with fans and teammates alike: "It's on me. I've got to make the kicks."
The 24-year-old from Derry, Northern Ireland, who made history earlier this season as the first undrafted Rutgers rookie to play in the NFL this year, is learning the harsh realities of professional football the hard way. His missed attempts came at a critical moment for the struggling Giants, putting additional pressure on rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart and the entire offense.
The Missed Opportunities
McAtamney's two failed extra point attempts proved costly in what became another disappointing loss for the Giants. Extra points, typically considered automatic in the NFL with a conversion rate above
94%, are moments where kickers are expected to deliver without fail. For a rookie trying to establish himself in the league, these misses represent more than just lost points—they're a test of mental fortitude.
Taking Accountability
Rather than deflecting blame or citing environmental factors, McAtamney faced the media head-on with refreshing honesty. His direct acknowledgment of responsibility stands in stark contrast to athletes who often hedge or make excuses after poor performances. This approach has earned him respect from Giants fans who appreciate authenticity, even in difficult moments.
"I'm embarrassed," McAtamney admitted in his post-game comments, showing the emotional weight these misses carried. For a player who crossed the Atlantic to pursue his NFL dream, the pressure of performing on football's biggest stage is immense.
The Rookie's Journey
McAtamney's path to the NFL is unconventional. After playing at Rutgers University, he went undrafted but earned a spot on the Giants roster through determination and skill. His debut earlier this season marked a milestone not just for him personally, but for Rutgers' undrafted free agent program.
The Irish kicker represents a growing trend of international players making their mark in American football, following in the footsteps of other successful Irish NFL kickers. However, success at this level requires not just physical ability but mental resilience—something McAtamney is being forced to develop quickly.
What This Means for the Giants
For a Giants team desperate for consistency in all phases, kicking reliability is crucial. The missed extra points add another layer of concern to a season that has already presented numerous challenges. With rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart trying to establish himself as the future of the franchise, the last thing the team needs is uncertainty in special teams.
The coaching staff now faces a decision: continue showing faith in the young kicker or explore other options. McAtamney's willingness to own his mistakes publicly may buy him additional opportunities to prove himself, but in the NFL, results ultimately matter more than words.
The Road Ahead
McAtamney's response to adversity will define his NFL career trajectory. History shows that many successful kickers have faced early struggles before finding consistency. The key is whether he can learn from these mistakes, make the necessary technical adjustments, and bounce back mentally.
His accountability is a positive sign. Rather than letting confidence erode completely, taking ownership can be the first step toward improvement. The Giants and their fans will be watching closely to see if this young kicker can transform this low point into a learning experience that strengthens his game.
For now, McAtamney's message is clear: he knows what's expected, he knows he fell short, and he's determined to do better. In the unforgiving world of NFL special teams, he'll get his chance to prove those words weren't empty.
Sources
1. 'It's on me. I’ve got to make the kicks' - Derry's McAtamney accepts blame for New York Giants loss
2. Jude McAtamney to become first Rutgers' undrafted NFL rookie to ...
3. Jude McAtamney sent a strong message to Jaxson Dart and Giants fans after missing two extra points
4. Sports Illustrated
5. Giants Kicker Jude McAtamney on his two missed extra points
6. K Jude McAtamney on missed extra points - Giants.com
