The chilling new Netflix series Monster: The Ed Gein Story has reignited a decades-old mystery: Did America’s most infamous “Ghoul of Plainfield” murder his own brother, Henry Gein? While the show dramatizes a Cain-and-Abel-style killing, the real story is far murkier—and far more unsettling.
The Official Story: A Deadly Fire and Lingering Doubts
In 1944, Henry Gein was found dead after a brush fire on the family’s Wisconsin farm. The official cause?
Asphyxiation from smoke inhalation. Local police ruled out foul play, and the coroner declared it an accident. Ed Gein himself led authorities directly to his brother’s body, which some found suspicious, but no autopsy was performed and the case was closed.
Yet, even at the time, there were whispers. Henry’s body had
bruises on his head and only minor burns, raising questions about whether the fire was really the cause of death. True crime author Harold Schechter later noted these inconsistencies in his biography
Deviant, but emphasized that there was never enough evidence to charge Ed with murder.
Netflix’s Dramatization vs. Historical Fact
The Netflix series doesn’t shy away from the speculation. In its opening episode, Ed is shown
striking Henry with a piece of wood and setting a fire to cover up the crime—a dramatic interpretation that has no basis in Ed’s own confessions or in police records. In reality, Ed Gein only ever admitted to two murders: Bernice Worden and Mary Hogan. He never confessed to killing his brother.
Why the Rumors Persist
So why does the theory persist? After Ed’s arrest in 1957 for the gruesome murders and grave robberies that would make him a household name, investigators and writers began to re-examine Henry’s death. The fact that Ed led police straight to the body, combined with the suspicious bruises and lack of a thorough investigation, fueled decades of speculation.
State investigator Joe Wilimovsky, cited in the 1981 biography
Edward Gein: America's Most Bizarre Murderer, raised questions about the circumstances, but ultimately,
no direct evidence ever linked Ed to his brother’s death.
The Legacy of Ed Gein—and the Unanswered Questions
Ed Gein’s crimes shocked the nation and inspired countless horror films, from
Psycho to
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. But the mystery of Henry’s death remains unsolved. Was it a tragic accident, or the first in a series of unspeakable acts? The truth may never be known.
What is clear is that Ed Gein’s legacy continues to haunt American culture—and that the line between fact and fiction is as blurred as ever.
What This Means for True Crime Fans
-
Netflix’s series takes creative liberties—don’t mistake dramatization for fact.
-
No confession or conclusive evidence ties Ed Gein to his brother’s death.
-
The case remains officially unsolved, but the speculation is likely to continue as long as Ed Gein’s story fascinates and horrifies.
For those drawn to the darkest corners of true crime, the mystery of Henry Gein’s death is a chilling reminder: sometimes, the scariest stories are the ones we’ll never fully unravel.
Sources
1. Did Ed Gein murder his brother Henry in real life? Netflix's 'Monster ...
2. Illegal coal mining case: ED raids multiple locations in Assam and ...
3. Did Ed Gein Really Kill His Brother? The Truth Behind 'Monster
4. Scientists find new blood group called MAL - The Economic Times
5. Did Ed Gein Actually Kill His Brother? The Truth About Henry ...
6. Ed Gein | Story, Movie, Netflix, Monster, Crimes, & Facts | Britannica
