The chilling saga of Nathan Carman—a story that has haunted New England for nearly a decade—has resurfaced in the national spotlight, thanks to a gripping new Netflix documentary. The film, The Carman Family Deaths, dives deep into the mysterious disappearance of Linda Carman and the suspicious circumstances surrounding her son Nathan, who was at the center of two tragic family deaths and a multi-million dollar inheritance scandal.
A Deadly Fishing Trip and a Family’s Nightmare
In September 2016, Nathan Carman and his mother Linda set out on a fishing trip near Block Island, Rhode Island. Only Nathan returned. After eight days adrift in a life raft, he was rescued by a passing freighter, but Linda was never found. The Coast Guard’s search became one of the largest in its history, but it was ultimately suspended without answers.
Nathan’s account of the events was immediately met with skepticism. He claimed their boat, the
Chicken Pox, sank suddenly, but investigators found evidence suggesting the vessel had been intentionally sabotaged. The tragedy was compounded by the fact that Nathan stood to inherit millions from his grandfather, John Chakalos, who had been murdered three years earlier in his Connecticut home—a crime that also remains unsolved.
The Netflix Documentary: Unraveling the Mystery
Netflix’s new documentary pulls no punches, exploring the tangled web of family secrets, forensic evidence, and legal drama that has made the Carman case a true crime sensation. The film features interviews with investigators, legal experts, and those close to the family, painting a portrait of Nathan as a troubled young man with a complicated relationship to both his mother and grandfather.
Key revelations include:
-
Forensic evidence suggesting the boat was deliberately altered to sink.
-
Nathan’s purchase of firearms and suspicious behavior before and after his grandfather’s murder.
-
Handwritten notes found in Nathan’s apartment detailing sniper rifles and improvised explosive devices.
-
A pattern of evasive answers and invocation of his Fifth Amendment rights during police questioning.
Public Reaction and Lingering Questions
The documentary has reignited public fascination—and outrage—over the case. Viewers are left grappling with the same questions that have stumped investigators for years: Did Nathan Carman kill his mother to claim a fortune? Was he also responsible for his grandfather’s brutal murder? Or is he, as he claims, a victim of tragic coincidence and relentless suspicion?
Legal experts interviewed in the film note that, despite mounting circumstantial evidence, Nathan was never convicted of either crime. The lack of a murder weapon in his grandfather’s case and the absence of Linda’s body have left prosecutors without the “smoking gun” needed for a conviction.
What’s Next for the Carman Case?
With the release of the Netflix documentary, calls for justice have grown louder. Some hope that renewed attention will bring forward new evidence or witnesses. Others see the case as a cautionary tale about the limits of the legal system when faced with cunning suspects and circumstantial evidence.
For now, the mystery endures—leaving a family shattered, a community on edge, and true crime fans riveted by one of the most perplexing cases in recent memory.
Sources
1. The Chilling Case of Nathan Carman's Deadly Fishing Trip
2. TIME | Current & Breaking News | National & World Updates
3. Netflix releases 'The Carman Family Deaths' documentary about former CT resident Nathan Carman
4. Did Nathan Carman Kill His Mother, Linda, During a 2016 Fishing Trip?
