The hockey world is buzzing after the Vegas Golden Knights signed goaltender Carter Hart to a professional tryout agreement, marking his dramatic return to the NHL following a year of legal turmoil and public scrutiny.
A Shocking Comeback After Legal Battles
Just over a year ago, Carter Hart’s career seemed all but over. In early 2024, Hart was placed on indefinite leave by the Philadelphia Flyers after being charged in connection with the 2018 Hockey Canada sexual assault scandal. The allegations led to his release from the Flyers, and Hart spent months fighting to clear his name.
The turning point came on July 24, 2025, when Ontario Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia found Hart not guilty of sexual assault. This verdict paved the way for his return to professional hockey. The NHL announced in September that Hart would be eligible to sign a contract on October 15 and could return to play on December 1.
Vegas Golden Knights Take a Risk
On October 16, 2025, the Vegas Golden Knights officially signed Hart to a professional tryout agreement, making headlines across the league. The move is seen as both bold and controversial, with fans and analysts divided over whether Hart deserves a second chance.
During his first press conference in Vegas, Hart addressed the media with a composed demeanor, expressing gratitude for the opportunity and emphasizing his focus on moving forward. “I’m here to work hard and earn my spot,” Hart said, acknowledging the challenges of the past year but refusing to dwell on them.
Mixed Reactions Across the NHL
The signing has sparked heated debate. Some analysts argue that Hart’s talent and mental resilience make him a valuable asset, citing his impressive track record with the Everett Silvertips and the Flyers, where he became the youngest goaltender in franchise history to win his NHL debut and a postseason game. Others, however, question the wisdom of bringing Hart back so soon after his legal troubles, suggesting the Golden Knights are taking a significant reputational risk.
Vegas fans are split, with some excited about the potential boost to their goaltending depth, while others remain wary of the off-ice baggage Hart brings. The Hockey News and other outlets have highlighted the uncertainty surrounding Hart’s future performance and the possible impact on team chemistry.
What’s Next for Carter Hart?
Hart’s eligibility to play begins December 1, and all eyes will be on his performance in training camp. If he can recapture his previous form, the Golden Knights may have landed a steal. But the pressure is on—both on the ice and in the court of public opinion.
For now, Hart’s story is one of redemption, resilience, and controversy. Whether he can turn the page and become a key player for Vegas remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Carter Hart’s return is the most talked-about comeback in hockey this year.
Sources
1. Dan’s Daily: Early Red Flags; All Sides of Carter Hart Signing; Inside Penguins Win
2. Carter Hart - Wikipedia
3. Carter Hart Press Conference | October 16, 2025 - YouTube
4. Carter Hart and Michael McLeod aren't worth it. | Canes Country
5. The Hockey News • News and Community
